Limits and Continuity

In this post, I am going to explain the concept of continuity in calculus in a bit more detail than when I touched on the subject in my previous post that explained one-sided limits.  I will have even more to say about the concept of continuity when I begin my series on derivatives soon, as derivatives can quite easily provide you with an assessment of the continuity of a graph.

As we've seen, limits calculus is a branch of mathematics that describes what a graph is doing as you approach a point on the graph and get infinitely close to it without ever actually reaching it.  It may be thought of as a way of predicting what a graph will do at a point, based on what the graph is doing in the general vicinity of that point.

For instance, if you imagine an upwards facing parabola, if you begin to trace the curve with your finger, moving towards the parabola's apex, you find that you seem to be approaching a predetermined point.  This holds true, in this example, if you are moving towards the apex from either the left side or from the right side.  Based on the curvature of the parabola, you can predict what the point will be as you approach it.  Also, you can see that the point actually is exactly what the line would predict it to be.  Since this is a simple example and very easy to visualize, you can intuitively understand just by looking at it that the graph is continuous.  There are no holes or anything weird going on along the length of the curve.  It is a smooth, continuous line.

However, if you consider a graph like the one I showed you when I talked about one-sided limits in calculus, you can very easily see, without any form of analysis at all, that the graph is discontinuous. You can't draw that line without lifting your pen off the paper.  In fact, this is a very crude but simple way of checking to see if a graph is continuous or discontinuous.

In calculus, limits can explain more than just what point a graph seems to be going towards.  Limits can be used to tell us about the continuity of a graph.  In fact, limits and continuity are very important parts of graph analysis.  If you want to know if a graph is continuous at a certain point, you merely need to look at the one-sided limits on both sides of that point, as well as the point itself.  If you look at the parabola above, and want to know if it's continuous at its apex, you consider the limit as you approach from the left, and also the limit as you approach from the right, and in this case you see that they both approach the apex.  There apex is also on the curve.  If the two one-sided limits equal the same number, and that number also evaluates to the same value at that point, you can conclude that the graph is continuous at that particular point.  For similar reasons, you can see that the second graph above is a discontinuous graph at x=5.

I will leave this example for you to draw and consider: imagine a normal parabola, as above, but it's apex is undefined (a hole in the graph).  The one-sided limits from both sides approach the same value, but at the apex the graph is undefined, which obviously doesn't equal the one-sided limits result.  Therefore, the graph would be discontinuous.

It should be fairly obvious, but I'd better state it here anyways, that this doesn't say anything about the continuity of the graph at any other point.  A graph could very well be continuous in one place and discontinuous somewhere else.  When examining the one-sided limits and the value at that point, you are only evaluating the continuity of the graph AT THAT POINT.  You are not evaluating the continuity of the graph as a whole.  It's safe to say, however, that if you have a point on a graph that is discontinuous, then you have a discontinuous graph overall.  To have a continuous function, you have to have continuity at every point on the graph.  That is to say, f(x) equals both of the one-sided limits for every value of x.

Most graphs that you will come across will be continuous, though you will need to pay special attention to functions that are piecewise as they may or may not be.  By definition, all polynomials are continuous.  So are rational functions (fractional expressions) except when the denominator is 0.  This is because a rational expression with 0 in the denominator is undefined, so it has no point on the graph.  So, obviously, it isn't continuous where there is no point!

So, to quickly summarize, to evaluate the continuity of a graph of f(x) at a specific point, you need to determine the one-sided limits as you approach that point from either side, and you also have to evaluate f(x) at that specific point.  If f(x) equals both one-sided limits, you have proven that the graph is continuous at that point.

I hope that this post makes sense and explains limits and continuity calculus for you.  If you need something to be explained better, or maybe a different example, please leave me a comment and I will add some more information.  Also, please +1 me below this if you found it useful, as it really helps me!  Thanks for reading.

One Sided Limits

Continuing on from my previous post in my series about limits in calculus, in this one I would like to better explain the concept of one-sided limits.  In my last post, I introduced you to the correct notation for writing a limit, though I mentioned that the notation that I was describing did not include any description of direction.

Recall my explanation for a limit, where I basically said that a limit (L) is the value that a graph appears to have at a specific point, assuming you were to follow along the curve and approach that point.  Kind of like making a prediction of the value of a point, based on what you know the curve is doing around it.  Now, with that definition in mind, you must realize that you can obviously approach the point in question from either side on the curve.  For simple equations (or more generally, continuous ones), you will approach the same limit value as you approach the "a" value from either side.  And this should intuitively make sense.  However, what I want you to consider now is something like the following example (a piecewise function):

What you can see in this example is that the value of f(x) for all values 5 and less equals 2, and for all values greater than 5 is 4.  Also, note the open and closed circle notation of the two lines.  The closed circle indicates that it includes 5 on that line.  The open circle indicates that it does not include 5 on the line, yet it contains all values up to 5, getting infinitely closer to it but yet never quite touching it.

So, from this example, now let me put the question to you: what is the limit of f(x) as x approaches 5?

To solve this question, you must consider one-sided limits, and examine the graph from either side of x=5.  If you consider what the graph "looks like it's going to do" as it approaches 5, you see that it kind of looks like it might be doing two different things.  (In fact, I will discuss continuity in separate post, though what we will see is that if you examine the limit at a value "a" from either side, and you determine that it is the same limit value for each one sided limit, then that is proof that the curve is continuous at "a").  If you approach x=5 from the left, you can see that it looks like the line will continue on as it has been doing, and the limit of f(x) when x=5 will be 2.  This is correct.  Consider the other part of the function, and approach x=5 from the right.  What does the limit appear to be?  Well, similarly to the left part, the right part appears to keep doing what it's doing, and the limit looks like it will be 4.  This is also correct.

So then, what I've shown here is that if I ask you to find the limit of f(x) as x approaches 5, you cannot give a single answer.  There are obviously two seemingly correct answers to this.  And so to distinguish between the two, you use the concept of one sided limits.  (Again, as I will explain in my post on continuity, you can obviously see by looking at the graph that the one sided limits on each side of 5 are not the same value, and therefore you can say that the graph is discontinuous at x=5.  Looking at the graph, you can immediately see this is true.)  You would say "as x approaches 5 from the right", or "as x approaches 5 from the left."  It is not overly complicated, but it is something to be aware of.

To make things less confusing, of course there is a correct notation to indicate one sided limits.  Thankfully, it is only a very small modification to the limits notation that I have already presented to you.  Specifically, all you have to do is add a "+" or a "-" to indicate which side of the point "a" you are approaching from.  It may be more helpful to consider the notation as referring to "all values greater than a" for the +, and "all values less than a" for the -.

Here is what the one sided limit notation looks like, for when x approaches a from either the right or the left, respectively:

 

This is a commonly used notation in calculus, and you will frequently see it when you are doing your limits mathematics homework.  Hopefully, now you will be able to understand the notation when you see it and be able to instantly translate it and apply it to what you see in the graph.  As I mentioned above, I will next provide a more formal discussion about the concept of continuity of graphs, and how you can determine whether a graph is continuous or not based on its equation.  As always, please remember to +1 this post if you found it useful!  Thanks!

Limit Notation in Calculus

This is going to be a very short post about a crucial subject in calculus: limts!  In my previous post, I gave a short and quite basic explanation of what is meant when we talk about limits in calculus.  I explained that they are similar to a concept that you know in everyday life, such as a speed limit, though they have their differences.  I also simply demonstrated that the value at a point on a curve does not necessarily equal the limit as you approach the point.  They require a different way to think about curves and graphs, in that where you are traditionally used to thinking about what happens exactly at a specific point on a graph (such as, what is the value of y when x equals 2), limits require you to consider what is happening to the curve as you approach a point and get infinitely closer to it.  Essentially, it may be thought of as "based on the shape of the curve that I know for sure, what does it look like the curve is going to do next?"  What it looks like it's going to do, the limit, might not always be exactly what it does do, which would be what the equation of the line would describe exactly.

So, that is a very brief overview of what my last post discussed, and over the next several posts, I will be expanding on this concept of limits, and explaining several different points about them and how to work with them.  First, however, I need to explain the notation for limits.  Limit notation in calculus is quite intuitive when you look at it.  That is, it is quite easy to understand when you see it.  Here is how you would write the symbol for a limit:

To read this, one would read it as "the limit of f of x, as x approaches a, equals L."

The "lim" part indicates that this is a limit, the "f(x)" (in this case) could be any function or expression, and the x→a part indicates the value "a" that x is approaching for which we want to evaluate the limit, L.  Let's consider the following graph again, the same one I drew in my introduction to limits post.

Now, say that we want to determine what the limit of this curve is (let's just call it the generic f(x)) as x→p (*note* assume for now that the point P is designated by the ordered pair (p,y)... tonight I'm too lazy to go back and edit my picture!).  We would write this expression as:

This expression reads as "the limit of f of x, as x approaches p."  Now, in this case, just by looking at the graph, we can visually see that if we trace the curve and move towards point P, where x=p, we can see that the curve is approaching y=4.  In other words, the limit is 4.

Similarly, refer back to my calculus limits introduction post, and you can see on the second example, where y=10 when x=p, the limit as x approaches p is also 4.

I hope that this series of posts is beginning to help you to grasp the concept of limits in calculus.  In my next post, I would like to develop this one a bit further, by introducing the concept of directional limits.  For the examples I've shown so far, we have only considered functions where the curve approaches the same point from both sides.  However, some graphs (e.g. piecewise equations) can have a different limit value, depending on which direction you approach "a" from.  I will explain these one-sided limits and their limit notation in the next post.

What are Limits in Calculus?

Back when I was taking my introductory calculus courses, one of the first topics that we covered was a section on limits and rates of change.  To a math student, "rate of change" kind of makes some sense.  It sounds like a math concept that explains how fast something is changing.  It's a fairly intuitive concept, and we will eventually see that it is a very important concept as well!  On the other hand, at first glance, the concept of a "limit" sounds a bit more abstract.  We all know about limits in terms of, for example, the speed limit for a car or other defined measures.  But how does this construct fit into calculus, or does "limit" mean something else entirely in this context?

The concept of a limit is essentially the same as when we're talking about a speed limit.  Let's say there is a posted speed limit of 50 mph.  Your car is not allowed to travel any faster than this.  So, imagine then what a graph would look like of the speed of your car over time.  At time = 0, you start stationary.  Then you accelerate and start driving a bit faster, until you get to the speed limit, at which point you don't go any faster (because we obey the laws!), and then you approach a stop sign and slow down to come to a stop.  When you look at the graph of what has just happened, you can see that the speed limit is basically a speed value that your car approaches.

In calculus, the concept of a limit is very similar, yet there is a slight difference that is very important.  In quite basic terms, a limit of a graph (or more accurately, a function) is a value that the graph approaches.  This concept is quite different from asking "what is the value at a point on the graph" because you may have a situation where the graph is non-continuous.  Here are a couple of examples that may clear up this concept of calculus limits.

For the first example, consider the following curve.  It is a smooth, continuous curve, meaning that there are no gaps or sudden jumps in the line.  (I will do a separate post on continuity of graphs in more detail soon.)  The limit of the graph as you move along the line towards the point P (getting infinitely closer but never actually reaching), from either direction, approaches the line of y = 4.  In this case, the graph actually does have a point at y = 4, because it is continuous.  So we can technically say that the limit as f(x) approaches point P is 4, and also that f(x) = 4.

Now, let's consider a discontinuous graph to see the importance of limits.  Recall what a function actually is, and specifically in this case think about piecewise functions, and also perhaps a refresher of the vertical line test would do well here as well.  In the below discontinuous graph, we can see that it is indeed a function because it passes the vertical line test.  It also appears to be a piecewise function, in that there appears to be a different expression that defines different parts of the graph (e.g. the curve, and also the point at P).  Note that on the curve, the point P is shown with an open circle to indicate all values that approach P, but not P.  P is elsewhere on the graph.  Similarly to the continuous expression above, as the curve of the graph approaches point P and gets infinitely closer without ever reaching it, it appears to be heading towards (i.e. the limit of the graph is) 4.  However, the expression f(x) itself clearly is not the same value exactly at P, and in this case we can see that when x = p, y actually equals 10 (while the limit is 4).

I know this has been a very basic explanation of limits, but I only intend for it to serve as an introduction to this calculus concept.  I will be posting additional material on other limit-related topics, including the correct limit notation, the concepts of one-sided limits, continuity of graphs, and asymptotes, and I will present some more introductory posts that discuss tangents, velocity, and rates of change.  And of course, what is a mathematical concept without having a set of laws to go with it?  So I will present to you, for your viewing pleasure, the Limit Laws.  I hope this introduction to limits has been enough to provide you with a basic understanding of what a limit of a function is, and how it differs from a regular expression that you are used to by now.  You can't think of these the same way as you have been regarding expressions up to now.  Before, you wanted to know what was happening AT a point.  With limits, you want to know what is happening AS YOU APPROACH a point.  They sound very similar, but they are distinctly different.  A good understanding of limits is essential for you to be able to work with other calculus problems and concepts.  I hope my coming posts will be helpful for you.  As always, please remember to +1 this if it helped you.

Free Printable Math Worksheets

Free Printable Math Worksheets

Free printable math worksheets are a terrific way for students to practice math skills.  By utilizing math worksheets, this can free the teacher from needing to take extra time to create practice math questions and problem sets.  Also, with the right math worksheets, students can learn cool math games and learn that math is fun.

This website can be used as a math resource for students and math teachers alike.  Anyone looking to practice their math skills or learn new math concepts should use these free printable math worksheets to practice and get good at solving mathematics problems.  Teachers looking for math worksheets and problem sets for their math students will also find this site to be very valuable to help them teach the mathematics concepts in their math classes.  These can be used as math print out worksheets, if you wish, or can just be copied down and worked out with a pencil and paper, just like students would do in school on a math test or math quiz.  If there is any topic in particular that anyone, teachers or students, would like me to be included, then please leave me a comment below and I will see what I can do.

I have found a great resource at Homeschoolmath.net that has all sorts of automatically generated math worksheets available for several elementary math grades.  Here's a link to their website that is loaded with free printable math worksheets.  There are worksheets specifically appropriate for grade 1 up to grade 6, and then several more worksheets that focus on specific math concepts.  I highly recommend visiting this site!

The following print out worksheets and problem sets are math questions that I have written on my own.  Feel free to download the files and print them out.  I will post answers as well, and I apologize in advance if there are any errors.  Again, please leave me a comment if you find an error and I will make the correction on the worksheet.

I hope that you find these math worksheets useful, and that they help you to more fully understand the topics and math concepts that I have discussed in other blog posts.  Feel free to leave feedback below, especially what you would like to see or what you would like changed.

Here are a few worksheets to get you started.  I will eventually be adding more to this list.  As teachers can agree with, creating math worksheets can take a lot of time... time which frequently could be better used to plan other aspects of their course curriculum.

Addition Worksheet 1 (with answer key)
Addition Worksheet 2 (with answer key)
Addition Worksheet 3 (with answer key)
Subtraction Worksheet 1 (with answer key)
Subtraction Worksheet 2 (with answer key)
Subtraction Worksheet 3 (with answer key)